877-786-4479
613-604-2188
If you are calling from a jail, please dial: 613-236-0535

Getting Firearms Back After Plea Can Be Complicated

The Police aren't alwys eager to return firearms after a person has been convicted.  A recent Ontario Court of Appeal decision highglights the difficulties an individual can face in getting his or her guns back after pleading guilty.

Andrew Shia is an avid hunter. He kept his guns at home, as he was authorized to do. He also had a closet full of marijuana plants at home, as he was not authorized to do.  One day, some police officers came to Andrew Shia's home. They were responding to a complaint of domestic violence. They looked around the home. They found the marijuana. And the guns. They seized both. They charged Andrew Shia with production of marijuana.

Andrew Shia hired a lawyer to defend him on the charge of production of marijuana. The lawyer thought that if Andrew Shia were to get an absolute discharge, the judge could not make a firearms prohibition order. So Andrew Shia pleaded guilty to production of marijuana. The judge found him guilty, acceded to a joint submission for an absolute discharge and made no firearms prohibition order under s. 109(1)(c) of the Criminal Code.

Andrew Shia thought his troubles were over. But, like his lawyer, he was mistaken. The police refused to return his guns. They said he could not get them back because, as a person found guilty of production of marijuana, he was prohibited from possessing firearms under s. 109(1)(c).

Ultimately, the Court of Appeal found a number of procedural irregularities, quashed the conviction and ordered a new trial.  However, Mr. Shia isn't out of the woods yet.  A fireams prohibition is mandatory for certain offencers, even if the indivdual receives a disharge.  Offences for which a prohibition is mandatory include: certain firearms offences, criminal harassment, and trafficking, possession for the purposes of traffikcing importing or producing a controlled substance.  The Shia case serves as a reminder that an individual should be aware of all of the potential consequences that may occur before entering a plea of guilty.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Our Location:

200 Elgin St.
Suite 500
Ottawa, ON K2P 1L5

Toll Free: 877-786-4479
Phone: 613-604-2188
Fax: 613-236-6958
Ottawa Law Office Map

Our Office
Getting Firearms Back After Plea Can Be Complicated | Bayne Sellar Ertel Carter